Thursday, April 16, 2020

Debate continues over whether DeSoto visited Indian village at Claiborne, Alabama in 1540

Monument at Claiborne tells of Indian village, Spanish explorers.

If you go to the intersection of Old Fort Claiborne Road and U.S. Highway 84 at Claiborne today, you will see a large stone monument that is believed to be the oldest historic marker in all of Monroe County.

I found myself passing through this part of the county the other day and took a few minutes to stop at this old monument as I had many times before. It sat there, much like it has for the past 81 years, a silent reminder that this spot was once important to Indians, Spanish explorers and the United States military. As 18-wheelers rumbled by on Highway 84, I made my way through the tall, green grass for a closer look.

Those of you who have been there before will know that the following words are inscribed into the marble face of the stone monument: Piache, an Indian town visited by DeSoto in 1540, was near here. DeLuna made a settlement here, Nanipagna, in 1560. Fort Claiborne was erected on the south bluff in 1813. LaFayette was entertained here, 1825. Erected by the Alabama Society of Colonial Dames, March 1939.

As I stood there looking west across the Alabama River and the Claiborne-Murphy Bridge, I thought about Hernando DeSoto and his men visiting this place in 1540. According to maps prepared by the University of Alabama, Piache (sometimes spelled “Piachi”) was located at Claiborne and other sources back this up as well. I’ve also heard tell that there are Indian mounds, deep in the woods, near where Limestone Creek empties into the brown waters of the Alabama River, so it’s not hard to believe that a sizeable population of Indians once lived in this area.

On the other side of the coin, I know that the location of Piache is somewhat of a historical controversy. The 1977 book “Dead Towns of Alabama” by W. Stuart Harris says that Piache was “probably” located where the town of Claiborne later stood but goes on to note that many historians believe the village was located on a high bluff on the east side of the Black Warrior River in Hale County. The 2018 book “Claiborne: A River Town” by Steve Stacey also points out that the DeSoto Commission of 1976 and the Alabama Desoto Commission of 1985 place Piache in Dallas County.

Stacey also makes mention of the Indian mounds along Limestone Creek, the largest of which is a burial mound about 100 feet long and 18 feet high. Many who ply the waters of the Alabama River will know that this sizeable creek flows into the river just north of Claiborne Landing. In days of old this would have been a paradise for native people, who would have enjoyed an abundant supply of fresh water, fish and wild game.

As I climbed back in my truck and headed back towards Monroeville, I thought about the generations of Indians who lived in this area for hundreds, maybe thousands, of years before the Spanish first set foot in what would later become Alabama. No doubt, especially if you know where to look, you can still see evidence of where the Indians left their mark on the land. One is left to wonder what artifacts lay just below the surface of the soil at Claiborne, never to see the light of day.

In the end, I’d be interested in hearing from anyone in the reading audience with more information about Piache, especially evidence that backs up the claim that it was located at Claiborne. Also, let me hear from you if you know of any old Indian mounds or village sites in that area. It would be a shame not to fully document this information for the generations of Monroe Countians yet to come.

No comments:

Post a Comment